Advertisement
If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.

Home Who's Online Today's Posts HP Calculator CompD Gift Shop Mark Forums Read
Go Back   Competition Diesel.Com - Bringing The BEST Together > Tech Area- Dodge > Dodge Tech > 94-98 2nd Gen. 12V
Register Members List Timeslips EFI Live Library Invite Your Friends FAQ Calendar Mark Forums Read

Closed Thread
 
Thread Tools
Old 09-16-2019, 11:15 PM   #1
Muddin_dude06
 
Muddin_dude06's Avatar

Name: Muddin_dude06
Title: ...
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Chandler OK
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 2,541
Which valve springs would you use?

Engine is ready to finally put back together. I have the 178/208 Hamilton cam degree’d and ready to go. I have a set of Hamilton 165 conical valve springs and a set of 60lb springs and PDD 10° retainers, which would you install? Is there any risk of unacceptable wear from the Hamilton’s higher spring rate? The engine is for my Farm truck/backup tow rig, probably keep the rpm’s to 3200 and under with a S300g to start (maybe small twins in the future if I get a wild hair). I’m only aiming for about 400 to maybe 450 engine HP. And does anyone know what Hamilton wants to see as far as how much Zinc is in the oil? I do oil analysis’ on everything here so I’ll be able to keep the zinc exactly where it needs to be. Thanks
__________________
'96 2500 4x4 5sp. 3” Full Long arm lift w/35's
ValAir DD Clutch w/ Input
DFI 5x.012’s, O-ringed, 625’s
Hamilton 178/208, pushrods, PDD street springs, S362sxe/.7WG

‘12 LML crew cab swb 4x4 RC 3.5” lift with 33’s
Anarchy tune
5” exhaust w/ Jones 5050XL
 
Old 09-24-2019, 06:06 AM   #2
tornado112
 
tornado112's Avatar

Name: tornado112
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: The Great Garden State
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 290
The 178 cam is great. I had the same goals for my truck. I was going with a bigger cam in my head but when i talke with zack he suggested the 178. He also said use the 24 valve tappets and 1 bottle of zinc is good for oil changes
.
__________________
94 Regular Cab Intake 5x12 Contagious Injectors 4kGSK and 60lb springs Adjustable Pump Gear and Timing Cover Auto Meter Steering Box Brace Sphon Adjustable Trac Bar Sphon Sway Bar Links Vision 19.5 Michelin 265-75-19.5 MegaTREK
 
Old 09-24-2019, 08:29 AM   #3
Mark Nixon
 
Mark Nixon's Avatar

Name: Mark Nixon
Title: No Savior among the flesh
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Brownville, Nebraska
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 8,676
Why are people having to run additives?
Why can't manufacturers build their stuff around what's available?
Why not have a better cam material, say billet, or a better surface hardening?

Why is it up to the consumer to make the designer's crap work?

Mark.
__________________
If you or I did business like the PEOPLE in government do business, we'd be put in jail. Government is coercive.
Anarchy: The state of existence where there are no masters & no slaves. Therefore, Anarchy means the ABSENCE OF SLAVERY, or, in other words, FREEDOM.
 
Old 09-24-2019, 10:05 AM   #4
bracker8040

Name: bracker8040
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jan 2007
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 818
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Nixon View Post
Why are people having to run additives?
Why can't manufacturers build their stuff around what's available?
Why not have a better cam material, say billet, or a better surface hardening?

Why is it up to the consumer to make the designer's work?

Mark.
Part of the issue tho is oil use to have more zinc in it, now it doesn’t. Zinc adds shear strength, and that is what a flat tappet cam needs to keep from killing the lobs. Add in ridiculously high spring pressure and the issue is magnified.
Roller lifters, high zinc oil, lighter spring pressure all help.

In regards to which springs, I’d run the 60lb springs.

Last edited by bracker8040; 09-24-2019 at 10:09 AM.
 
Old 09-24-2019, 08:29 PM   #5
kawi600
 
kawi600's Avatar

Name: kawi600
Title: got Coal for Christmas
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: communist urban hell
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 861
I ran synthetic oil alone and wiped a cam lobe on mine. only had his mild street cam and 110# springs. Problem is as last poster said, removal of zinc and some other high-pressure wear metals to avoid catalytic converter damage. Essentially, the EPA threw a wrench in your old diesel (planned obsolescence).
flat tappet motors with high spring rates, higher lift put more pressure on the tappet and need that additive to prevent wear. The stock springs and cam can run just fine on the normal oils.
I got an email back from Zach ages ago about ZDDP content and went back to look, they recommend at least 1750 ppm ZDDP. I have used lucas and cam shield with good results.
__________________
Psalm 144
Psalm 37:10,11
Isaiah 65:20
 
Old 09-24-2019, 08:48 PM   #6
Mark Nixon
 
Mark Nixon's Avatar

Name: Mark Nixon
Title: No Savior among the flesh
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Brownville, Nebraska
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 8,676
Quote:
Originally Posted by bracker8040 View Post
Part of the issue tho is oil use to have more zinc in it, now it doesn’t. Zinc adds shear strength, and that is what a flat tappet cam needs to keep from killing the lobs. Add in ridiculously high spring pressure and the issue is magnified.
Roller lifters, high zinc oil, lighter spring pressure all help.

In regards to which springs, I’d run the 60lb springs.
You kinda' missed my point.
Point is, the lubricant should not have to carry the design issues soft metals create.
My point is made, in that by removing the zinc, cams go flat, unless it's made of stronger material and/or surface hardness.

Another thing, lifters do NOT contact the whole profile of the cam lobe, rather both are designed in such a way as to rotate the lifter, not just scrub the whole foot.
That alone should tell you it's more about the actual hardness of the material, than the lubricity of the oil.

Yes, excessive spring pressure may play a notable role, but then, cam manufacturers selling cams they KNOW will see excessive loads need to consider better, stronger materials towards that market.

Mark.
__________________
If you or I did business like the PEOPLE in government do business, we'd be put in jail. Government is coercive.
Anarchy: The state of existence where there are no masters & no slaves. Therefore, Anarchy means the ABSENCE OF SLAVERY, or, in other words, FREEDOM.
 
Old 09-24-2019, 10:02 PM   #7
bracker8040

Name: bracker8040
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jan 2007
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 818
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Nixon View Post
You kinda' missed my point.
Point is, the lubricant should not have to carry the design issues soft metals create.
My point is made, in that by removing the zinc, cams go flat, unless it's made of stronger material and/or surface hardness.

Another thing, lifters do NOT contact the whole profile of the cam lobe, rather both are designed in such a way as to rotate the lifter, not just scrub the whole foot.
That alone should tell you it's more about the actual hardness of the material, than the lubricity of the oil.

Yes, excessive spring pressure may play a notable role, but then, cam manufacturers selling cams they KNOW will see excessive loads need to consider better, stronger materials towards that market.

Mark.

I agree with you that better material should be used, but look at it this way. Do you really think that an aftermarket parts supplier that’s using steel made in China, and can tell their customers that they have to run zinc to keep the parts alive, and therefore sell “cheap” parts at a healthy markup, and have no liability if the customer doesn’t follow those instructions and the parts fail, why would they bother changing anything?
This is one of the things that aggravates me about a lot of the diesel aftermarket. The quality of so many parts and materials is pitiful.

Last edited by bracker8040; 09-24-2019 at 10:04 PM.
 
Old 09-24-2019, 10:22 PM   #8
Mark Nixon
 
Mark Nixon's Avatar

Name: Mark Nixon
Title: No Savior among the flesh
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Brownville, Nebraska
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 8,676
We're 100% on the same page, then.
Wasn't trying to be a jerk, just ticks me off that quality has to suffer, along with customer satisfaction, over what amounts to saving pennies on the dollar, in a mass market scenario.

I tear apart damaged engines for a living and I see destroyed 6.7s over stupid stuff like seats falling out and rod bolts backing off.
Both are very real and prevalent problems, with, I feel, tuners and turbos exacerbating the issue.

Mark.
__________________
If you or I did business like the PEOPLE in government do business, we'd be put in jail. Government is coercive.
Anarchy: The state of existence where there are no masters & no slaves. Therefore, Anarchy means the ABSENCE OF SLAVERY, or, in other words, FREEDOM.
 
Old 09-25-2019, 11:00 AM   #9
bracker8040

Name: bracker8040
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jan 2007
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 818
I like diesels, and I like diesel performance, but a lot of the diesel performance industry (parts quality, reliability, etc) is almost laughable.
Look at Hot Rod Magazines Drag Week versus UCC for example.
The cars that compete in that event race at 5 different tracks, on 5 different days, have to DRIVE between events, (often close to 1,000 miles of street driving, so that means they have to be street legal) carrying ALL their tools, tires, etc WITH THE COMPETING VEHICLE.
The cars at the top of that event AVERAGE in the low 6 second range at over 200 mph in the 1/4 mile for the week!
The UCC trucks ARE heavier, but they’re 50% slower, probably couldn’t survive a 50 miles street drive without some sort of catastrophic failure, and definitely couldn’t carry all their support equipment.
The diesel performance world is way behind the gas world, sadly, in terms of reliability, versatility, and raw performance.
Anyway, that’s my rant. I’ll quit mucking up this this thread with it.

Last edited by bracker8040; 09-25-2019 at 11:02 AM.
 
Old 09-25-2019, 12:36 PM   #10
TheHammer
 
TheHammer's Avatar

Name: TheHammer
Title: broke
Status: Not Here
Join Date: May 2012
Location: juneau wi
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 738
Out of the two options the 60lbs shimmed would be my choice with that cam. Also on the oil topic I have found that the engines I pull apart that don’t run additional zinc and a friction reducer have an obvious amount of wear in comparison.
 
Old 09-25-2019, 02:41 PM   #11
Rich dzl
 
Rich dzl's Avatar

Name: Rich dzl
Title: 12v guru
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Mar 2011
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 741
Everyone complains about adding zinc and adding fuel lube in mechanical pumps . Added zinc/lube Is insurance for your engine.
 
Old 09-25-2019, 09:04 PM   #12
chevota84
 
chevota84's Avatar

Name: chevota84
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Prineville, OR
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 4,926
Quote:
Originally Posted by bracker8040 View Post
I like diesels, and I like diesel performance, but a lot of the diesel performance industry (parts quality, reliability, etc) is almost laughable.

Look at Hot Rod Magazines Drag Week versus UCC for example.

The cars that compete in that event race at 5 different tracks, on 5 different days, have to DRIVE between events, (often close to 1,000 miles of street driving, so that means they have to be street legal) carrying ALL their tools, tires, etc WITH THE COMPETING VEHICLE.

The cars at the top of that event AVERAGE in the low 6 second range at over 200 mph in the 1/4 mile for the week!

The UCC trucks ARE heavier, but they’re 50% slower, probably couldn’t survive a 50 miles street drive without some sort of catastrophic failure, and definitely couldn’t carry all their support equipment.

The diesel performance world is way behind the gas world, sadly, in terms of reliability, versatility, and raw performance.

Anyway, that’s my rant. I’ll quit mucking up this this thread with it.
One went 5.99 this year. Pretty crazy.

Sent from my SM-G965U using Tapatalk
__________________
99 Dodge 2500 with stuff
 
Old 10-09-2019, 01:41 PM   #13
Texashighways

Name: Texashighways
Title: Comp Diesel Sponsor
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Apr 2013
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 401
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mark Nixon View Post
You kinda' missed my point.
Point is, the lubricant should not have to carry the design issues soft metals create.
My point is made, in that by removing the zinc, cams go flat, unless it's made of stronger material and/or surface hardness.

Another thing, lifters do NOT contact the whole profile of the cam lobe, rather both are designed in such a way as to rotate the lifter, not just scrub the whole foot.
That alone should tell you it's more about the actual hardness of the material, than the lubricity of the oil.

Yes, excessive spring pressure may play a notable role, but then, cam manufacturers selling cams they KNOW will see excessive loads need to consider better, stronger materials towards that market.

Mark.
On the Cummins flat tappet cams, they are flat. Flat lobes carry more load than tapered lobes. The lobe to tappet offset gives a bit of rotation not taper. We offer a steel cam that is made in the USA, and it still needs zinc..... We sell chillcast ductile cams not to save a buck but because most people will not go through the expense of installing bushings in the block to be able to run steel cams. Cummins, to save a few bucks decided not to put bushings in all seven cam bearings, something that they have fixed on the 2019 HO engines. Flat tappet cams although they open faster at lower lifts than roller cams are on their way out. With low zinc, low additive package oils, rollers are the only option moving forward. I have offered higher end steel cams in the past and they just did not sell. Unfortunately, customers vote with their dollars which products are viable.


A side note, on every block we sell, we only offer 7 cam bearings. Steel cams, with steel tappets would be the only things we sell if it was my choice. My 2014 at 7500miles got torn down for research. It was already wiping a lobe. Short duration and small diameter cams have wear issues..... Adding duration increases the radius at the nose of the cam and can support more pressure due to having more area in contact with the tappet across the nose. The same with larger diameter cams, they GREATLY increase the nose radius. THe issue is that there is not much room to go much larger in the block. Our 62mm cams are pushing it.
__________________
Hamilton Cams
1.512.355.9101
 
Old 10-12-2019, 09:44 AM   #14
K204DR
 
K204DR's Avatar

Name: K204DR
Title: I'm the Driver
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: TN
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 971
so how do the original cams run for 500k without wiping? what are you doing different?
__________________
88 Chevy crewcab 6bt nv4500 valair clutch
 
Old 12-29-2019, 04:00 PM   #15
Bersaglieri
 
Bersaglieri's Avatar

Name: Bersaglieri
Title: Ron Swanson's Brother
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Ohio
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 1,957
I'm marking this for info. I'm in the same boat with the same cam and spring options.

I would say the original cams durability is due to spring rates and/or lobe design. Both being tame and being designed for longevity/emissions rather than performance. I will mention that my stock ~250,000 mile cam in an all stock 12v motor has pitting on a few lobes and lifters with only 250,000 miles. Stock cams are not inspected very often and I suspect that many have similar wear, however most people just don't notice cause they run their truck until it blows or is traded.
__________________
2013 - ISBe - Aisin - AAM
1997 - 6BT - G56 - Dana "Overworked and Underpaid"
2002 - 6BT - 47RH - Sterling [Excursion]
1994 - LT1 - 4L80e - Moser
 
Old 12-29-2019, 04:18 PM   #16
ofelas
 
ofelas's Avatar

Name: ofelas
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Oct 2015
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 285
Install a mechanical oil temp gauge & get your oil hot enough to boil off any condensation/moisture.

I've pulled plenty a stock cam with no lobe pitting.
__________________
Oversized exhaust tips are false advertising, just like the banana shoved down your britches.
 
Old 12-29-2019, 04:23 PM   #17
biggy238
 
biggy238's Avatar

Name: biggy238
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Just North of Wrong
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 10,821
Quote:
Originally Posted by ofelas View Post
Install a mechanical oil temp gauge & get your oil hot enough to boil off any condensation/moisture.

I've pulled plenty a stock cam with no lobe pitting.
And the one I pulled out of the short block I built was pitted to hell.

I agree about short cycle driving. That will kill any engine prematurely.

Sent from my motorola one vision using Tapatalk
__________________
Check out @bdmaximusworx

05.5 Campanella White TDi Jetta 5spd 45.5MPG
-Little Sexy
'10 Silver F250 CCLB 4X4 6.4L cummins Swapped
Insta @trash.panda250
 
Old 01-11-2020, 09:43 AM   #18
Muddin_dude06
 
Muddin_dude06's Avatar

Name: Muddin_dude06
Title: ...
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Chandler OK
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 2,541
Well I ended up changing my plans for valve springs. After PDD’s video where they were talking about coil bind and X number of pounds at X lift height I figured I would check that stuff since it was easy to do and it was something I had never thought about before. I measured my installed height for both the 60 pounders and the Hamilton springs I have and then checked them both. My 60’s were way closer to coil bind than I was really comfortable with, and for whatever reason my Hamilton springs fell about .030” shorter than their minimum installed height so the pressure was way higher than I was ok with. So I ordered some of the PDD street conical. They measured 170 on the seat and 320 at full lift on the exhaust and were not close to being coil bound. So I swapped them in last night.
__________________
'96 2500 4x4 5sp. 3” Full Long arm lift w/35's
ValAir DD Clutch w/ Input
DFI 5x.012’s, O-ringed, 625’s
Hamilton 178/208, pushrods, PDD street springs, S362sxe/.7WG

‘12 LML crew cab swb 4x4 RC 3.5” lift with 33’s
Anarchy tune
5” exhaust w/ Jones 5050XL
 
Old 01-12-2020, 08:58 AM   #19
YOUNG GUNS15
 
YOUNG GUNS15's Avatar

Name: YOUNG GUNS15
Title: Im AWESOME!!!!
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Utah
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 7,346
Which valve springs would you use?

I think a common problem is that a lot of people who buy camshafts don’t understand valve springs. I certainly didn’t, I relied on what has been done, current technology, and what worked for others. Now technology has progressed, and outdated what I thought were the best valve springs for my setup.

I’d venture to say that most aftermarket camshaft failings in our cummins engines, are due to improper valve spring setup and the sudden shift away from zinc in all oils. Those two things alone are at the root of the problem. My engine in Ol’ Blue was built in 2013/2014. I used the correct additives for the oil from day one, and bought the standard for valve springs and a 200/220, but looking at it now, they are definitely very close to coil bind with a 200/220 camshaft. (I had issues with factory valve seals getting smashed due to the amount of lift, beehive springs were being compressed quite a fair amount) Some of the evidence is in the updated cam retainer. I had it apart for a timing case seal. It is already seeing some slight wear, less than 10,000 miles.

I’ll add that PDD’s video really helped me understand valve springs further, for visual learners like me, that video was the ticket. Only problem now is I need different springs to keep my cam retainer from taking a beating.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
__________________
Spence
-1994 4x4 12 valve 13mm, single 475 748/1292 Fuel 872/1470 N2O
-2005 4x4 12 valve CCSB 3rd gen '12-rail' 280hp
 
Old 02-03-2020, 08:05 AM   #20
Destroked 450
 
Destroked 450's Avatar

Name: Destroked 450
Title: Too Much Time
Status: Not Here
Join Date: Mar 2015
Location: Harned,Ky.
Member`s Gallery
Posts: 340
Valve spring coil bind and retainer to guide clearance has been something I dealt with for years on performance gas engines, even through my cam isn't very big I checked those things when I installed the Big Stick and 60# springs.
__________________
Mine: 04 F-450 sc 4x4 fb drw 5.9 12v 215 ppump, zf6, kdp fixed, 3k gsk, AFC Live, super b single, pusher intake, d-celerator ebrake
Hers:2018 F-150 sc 4x4 5.0
Farm trucks: 01 Z71 ext cab, 95 S10, 93 F-800 8.3 Cummins, 87 AM General 5 ton
 
Closed Thread

Thread Tools

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:22 AM.

 


Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2006 - 2024, CompetitionDiesel.com
all information found on this site is property of www.competitiondiesel.com