I got a question

Status
Not open for further replies.
If Charles is working on the plane, I would start praying.

I find it disturbing if anyone bases their religious practices on a,

"Just in case."

scenario. I think that misses the message.

I have a question. If the preachers were meant to do what they do on a volunteer basis, how many would leave the fold?
 
.....it's simply believing and practicing what the Bible says. It does not force anyone to believe anything, it simply explains how you get to heaven and how can go to hell.

I've been into that argument before, its a promise of Heaven, or a threat to go to Hell.

If believing is so glorious, why must the big Guy threaten us with Hell?
 
David.... you can call it whatever you like and it won't change a thing. Let me take your exact paragraph, and simply change a few things around to give you a good jolt...


Here's your original:

Charles
There is the problem, the word religion that MAN made up to suit his own good.
The Bible is not a religion, Christianity is not a religion, it's simply believing and practicing what the Bible says. It does not force anyone to believe anything, it simply explains how you get to heaven and how can go to hell.

Okay, now try this on for size:

Powerstroke Racer (The Muslim) said:
Charles
There is the problem, the word religion that MAN made up to suit his own good.
The Koran is not a religion, Islam is not a religion, it's simply believing and practicing what the Koran says. It does not force anyone to believe anything, it simply explains how you get to Paradise and how can go to Jahannum.



All I did was replace the words of your religion.....err, whatever you want to call it, with those of Islam.

Now how do you suppose you're so different, and how do you suppose that the bible is so much better than the Koran? Were they both not the divine word of the omnipotent superpower of the universe?

Oh, wait, I forgot. Yours is the right one. I forgot for a second there.
 
I've been into that argument before, its a promise of Heaven, or a threat to go to Hell.

If believing is so glorious, why must the big Guy threaten us with Hell?

There is nothing to argue about, you either believe it or not.

Do you steal or break the law without expecting consequences ???
Do you honestly expect that you could do wrong/break the law and get away with it????
Biblical principles are no different, obey them and you get rewarded, disobey them and you go to hell, pretty simple.
 
Last edited:
David.... you can call it whatever you like and it won't change a thing. Let me take your exact paragraph, and simply change a few things around to give you a good jolt...


Here's your original:



Okay, now try this on for size:





All I did was replace the words of your religion.....err, whatever you want to call it, with those of Islam.

Now how do you suppose you're so different, and how do you suppose that the bible is so much better than the Koran? Were they both not the divine word of the omnipotent superpower of the universe?

Oh, wait, I forgot. Yours is the right one. I forgot for a second there.

Charles
Let be clear on the subject, The OP posted in the Diesels for Christ section of CompD, not Diesels for allah or any other form of god/prophet etc.
I said I believe in the Bible and what the Bible says, I never said that I disagree with any other book. I am not going to even try and argue what others believe or do not believe only what I believe and why in the section of CompD dedicated to Diesel for Christ.
 
I am almost done with this argument, its the same one that has raged for thousands of years and divided people throughout history. To each their own, but this is the reason that I am, for now, done with religion in general. Ill come back after a break, but my entire life i have been inundated with this mess, and i need a break!
 
There is nothing to argue about, you either believe it or not.

Do you steal or break the law without expecting consequences ???
Do you honestly expect that you could do wrong/break the law and get away with it????
Biblical principles are no different, obey them and you get rewarded, disobey them and you go to hell, pretty simple.

There is a difference- you can do anything you want, including murder, but if you accept Jesus Christ as your savior, good to go!! I expect death row boys are about 99.9% have found Jesus.
On the other hand, lets say someone(not me) has lived a good life, helped the poor, never cheated or stole was a good steward of the earth, basically a do un to others type of guy. If he doesn't believe hes screwed.
Or lets say he died quickly before he was educated enough on the matter to make a real choice?

Pretty rotten deal.

Perhaps there is exceptions to the rule, that Jim Baker types haven't let us in on?
 
Charles
Let be clear on the subject, The OP posted in the Diesels for Christ section of CompD, not Diesels for allah or any other form of god/prophet etc.
I said I believe in the Bible and what the Bible says, I never said that I disagree with any other book. I am not going to even try and argue what others believe or do not believe only what I believe and why in the section of CompD dedicated to Diesel for Christ.

Nice cop out.

Why don't you just admit you don't want to talk about the fact that most every other religion feels exactly as you feel about "non-believers"...... about YOU!


Secondly...

I said I believe in the Bible and what the Bible says, I never said that I disagree with any other book.

Well I've got plenty of science books that perfectly explain the evolutionary process of humans. I don't recall anywhere in there where it mentions anything about this guy Adam...

You see...

Because of what you've come to see as perfection in your own book, you refuse to acknowledge objective data like I just mentioned in another book. Even though yours is based in conjecture and hearsay, whereas the second is based in observed, tested and verified data.

I don't think we need any more examples to show how much your current beliefs mar your ability to think reasonably and intelligently about your surroundings.

The first step to you having a real discussion here (unlikely) is for you to at least be real with your own position...
 
Charles,
Listen to me, their idea of god is at least as good as our thoughts of the big bang, Its a Mind F. Let me throw something at you.

What if there was a god and he was the singularity, he came out the singularity and said now you will explode. WHAM! He created all the science all the physics he created everything. then he tried to explain it to BC man. and man screwed it up in its books. Then he put jesus in a womans womb and said he is my son, and he watched like you and i watch and was agitated, ANGRY that people wouldnt listen. He might have said screw this world; i leave them to their own and flew off to different worlds and made smarter better people who made real scientific bibles

man is corrupt by nature maybe he was just partially Omniscient, and the other worlds evolved in better ways and he was pleased and help them.

maybe he flew back to earth and looked at it from the dark side of the moon and thought who the hell is this Swaggert dumbass, who are all these false Prophets, I will leave them to their own, he could have wized off to Andromeda or the clouds of Magellan where he had succeeded and just wanted to be left alone, he was already pissed at us when he destroyed Sodom and Gomorah, maybe he said this species is crazy, i will leave them alone and let them choose their path. They think too much when they should just believe.

Does that mean he dont exist? It just means maybe he made us first and F'ed up then tried to fix it with jesus and got pissed that we wouldnt listen and did better on other planets

If he rocked Egypts world with the plaques and split the Red Sea and people still wouldnt listen maybe he got fed up with us and just split and said these dam humans think too much and wont listen.

I left the Meth lab the other morning and drove to Hotel Ponder i get there and I dont have my hotel keys. i sit there at 3:00 am and think about it. i think i know i locked the Meth lab up, i then got a shirt out the back of my Camry i bet i set those dam keys on the hood like i do sometimes when i get Gas and put a coke on the hood. i went back out there right then and stared at the road thinking my keys are on this road!

Its 10 years of keys, i need them, i look all around the trailer, cant find them, i drive to the store at daybreak at 10 miles per hour, cant find em, cant see them. Then i come out the meth lab at noon, i am like these dam keys must be in the ditch i am hacking with my machete searching for hours the ditches on that road, cant find em.

I hear a car coming and i turn around and walk away, i got on rubber boots, shorts and no shirt. I hear the car pull into the horse pen of Mr lees son in law and a beautiful girl gets out, i walk up to her and say look as you go down this gravel road, if you see any keys they are mine, i say i am senile in my old days and i think i might have set them on the roof when i opened my back door she laughs and says i do that with cokes when i get gas.

I turn around and i am hacking the ditches with my machete and i say God please give me my keys back, i figure they are in the dam ditch, i then hear a car approach and its her and she has her windows down and says they were right at the end of the road where you turned. Its a big hill there and i will turn and go down the side of the raod where i wont get hit by a logging truck

Maybe i was just blind or maybe god decided to give them back to me. I dont know but when she handed them to me i Hollered THERE IS A GOD!

keys.jpg


was i just blind, i had been over that same area 2 times, she saw them right off

Does it prove there is a god, NO. I just puzzles me that sometimes in life, when it seems hopeles, i call out to god and things go right. I'll bring you in a cave charles and i bet you one thing you will hear him talking to you, in complete sentences, if that dont work lets go to baton rouge and lets drop Acid and you may hear him speak

I say we try the cave first, i have got a set of OMS121's which used to hold more air than any other cylinder. We will crank them and my 104's to 4500 and do a buddy dive and i will get you a half mile in the cave and look at you and write on my slate:

DO YOU BELIEVE IN GOD? and you will i garontee you will, he will be talking to you telling you things

Conan the barbarians god was CROM, Crom was an angry got of the Cimmerians who just gave them physical strength at birth, Conan would curse crom, he would holler "BY CROM" when he was in a bad situation, one day Crom looked down on him and helped him. you will have to read alot of the books by robert howard to find when that happened
 
Wow. :clap:

Why is Charles not touching that? The bible was written by man, The Koran was written by man, both in a time when Jupiter was the gods of the Greeks, when Odin was God of the Vikings. They were promiscuous and vengeful gods, They had sex with Humans, That is what man believed then, how could we possible expect Man then to write it down right. They could have been leery to leave the norm and screwed it all up.

Earth might have been his first planet his first idea to let lightning bolts hit the water and form amino acids and evolve into bacteria, he might have floated there for a billion years and watched what he created, just stared at it. he was the inventor of evolution. He might have decided okay this one didnt work out, but i will not destroy them, i spent too much time and energy making them, i will do better on my next planet.

I,d like to believe there is a planet where the bible is a physics book and Newtons, Maxwell, liebenitz, Descartes, Galileo, ideas are called gods rules and Platos idea of a Just society and the pure enjoyment a man feels by looking at a flower are the rule of law. not the selfish need as plato said of a man who eats because he is hungry and thinks it is a pure pleasure.

I have a dream!
 
On a final note, what is the riddle of steel. Conan believed in Crom

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PE1tyh6ediQ&feature=related

the movie is week however and Schwarzenegger didnt do Conan justice. first off Conan wouldnt have been that pumped up and he had short black hair. they could climb cliffs like rock climbers. They wouldnt have naturally been that big.

maybe our god is like Crom and sits outside Alpha Proxima and wonders what is wrong with us.

the riddle of Steel which this movie F's up is what is more powerful Flesh or Steel? I think it was showed later in the movie when Conan battles Thus Amun and Thus looks at him and tells the riddle and say look, he points to a young girl on a cliff and she jumps to her death. flesh is more powerful than steel because when a man/woman truly believes something, they will die for it.

How many Christians today would jump off a cliff if Swaggert told them God said to do it? Find your own truth!
 
On a final note, what is the riddle of steel. Conan believed in Crom

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PE1tyh6ediQ&feature=related

the movie is week however and Schwarzenegger didnt do Conan justice. first off Conan wouldnt have been that pumped up and he had short black hair. they could climb cliffs like rock climbers. They wouldnt have naturally been that big.

maybe our god is like Crom and sits outside Alpha Proxima and wonders what is wrong with us.

the riddle of Steel which this movie F's up is what is more powerful Flesh or Steel? I think it was showed later in the movie when Conan battles Thus Amun and Thus looks at him and tells the riddle and say look, he points to a young girl on a cliff and she jumps to her death. flesh is more powerful than steel because when a man/woman truly believes something, they will die for it.

How many Christians today would jump off a cliff if Swaggert told them God said to do it? Find your own truth!


Truth is an objective thing. What is true is true and what is false is false. Perspective has zero influence on either.

Just as there are no "sides" to a story recalling an event. There was an event, and that's that. People who think in terms of "sides to every story" are assuming that everyone else is as close-minded and childish as they are. They can't fathom the idea that someone could offer an objective account of an event without twisting it into their favor and making up a "story" to bolster their "side".


I think that's what I find most frustrating in discussions like this one. People are all assuming that everyone is just tossing out their own opinion and clinging to it for dear life, no matter what.

When in reality, the religious people (by nature) are doing just that, while those like myself are merely accepting of the BEST explanation. Let me say that again..... we are most interested in the BEST explanation, not necessarily the explanation being put forth at present. If tomorrow new evidence is uncovered that requires the explanation(s) to be altered as new information is gained then they WILL BE.... With excitement no less, as the explanation becomes that much STRONGER each time new information is brought to bare that fine tunes it. Or in the case of information that turns the world on it's ear.... ALL THE BETTER, as even a complete re-assessment due to new info is a WONDERFULLY good thing, as the TRUE understanding grows by leaps and bounds in such cases.

On the other hand, you've got those clinging to the bible in this thread who are NOT EVER going to adjust their world view in light of ever increasing information gained. EVER!!!

They DO have a side to a STORY.... and one they will not even acknowledge to be capable of error.... as EVERYTHING is..... most CERTAINLY stories written in a book by men who lived at a time when something as simple as a light bulb was beyond the grasp of even the most intelligent minds on the planet.


Between the two of us we run into a situation where their mindset has them believe those like myself are stuck in their opinion the same as they are. But the reality is that those like myself are stuck in LOGIC and RATIONAL thinking.... and because of this are UNABLE to accept bs when everything in the universe aside from one little compilation of stories proves this to be the case.

On the one hand we have all the observable evidence in the universe, compiled over billions and billions of years, and on the other we have a compilation of short stories written by men who lived at a time when people were completely ignorant to the workings of the world they lived in.

I'm sorry for continually pointing out the obvious, but that's not a situation of "opinion" or "preference" or "finding your own way"....

You don't have "sides to a story" so-to-speak..... you have a whole book of stories.... vs an entire universe of EVIDENCE.....


While it may be comforting to think about a man delivering presents around the world in a single night, shimmying down chimneys, floating through walls and just knowing who's naughty and nice.... the simple TRUTH is that the parents put out the presents and take a bite of the cookies themselves...

No matter HOW many people want to "believe" that a chubby little man does it, the TRUTH is what it is. It's not up to opinion..... it's not up to interpretation..... There are no "sides" to it....

And what we've got here are a bunch of people who still believe in santa. When they ask..... do you believe??? It's no different than one 4yr old asking another the SAME question about SANTA CLAUSE! And then when they say that you cannot enjoy all that could be given to you if you do not believe, it is NO different than the 4yr old telling another that they cannot get the presents if they don't believe.... When people say you will burn in hell..... the 4yr old says you'll go on the naughty list and won't be allowed any presents.

Santa = Jesus
Believing = Believing
Presents = Heaven
Naughty list = Hell


The fact that nearly all of us were duped into the Santa Story and had our world turned on it's ear makes it hard for me to understand how the same people cannot even FATHOM how it could happen again, when the SAME mechanism is in place.

Give the people a list of things to do. Ten commandments, vs what is it..... you better no shout, you better not pout, you better not cry I'm telling you why......

Hmmmm, so we have a list of commandments of what you're not supposed to do. Okay. Check.

And then give them motivation for staying in line. Blissful eternal heaven for the adults, and bountiful presents for the children at Christmas. Motivation, check...

And fear of straying.... Okay, the most unimaginable torturous fire and suffering for all of eternity in hell. A little over-the-top IMO, but gets the point across nonetheless... For the children.... well we've got the naughty list and NO PRESENTS!!! Oh NO!


It's the SAME behavioral control mechanism. One is in place for adults, and one for young children. Both are useful in shaping behavior. I doubt we'll find very many advocating the validity of the Santa Story above the age of 5. Yet we have plenty advocating the validity of the second. And for valid, logical reasons? Of course not, lol. For absolute crap reasons made up by man.

It's nuts.
 
Charles
Pick up a Bible and read Acts 9:3-19
or
Acts 9:3-19 - PassageLookup - BibleGateway.com

I'll pray the same thing happens to you.


I don't need to read any fairy tales, nor any horror stories to live my life. I've got a whole shelf full of good movies at home if I need either.

Thanks...



The fact that you think stories written in a book based on the hallucinations of others is a credible information source pretty much defines why no real discussion can take place.

You should start by at least fixing the obvious errors in your book of reference before you worry about pawning it off on others.

Let me know how the church adamantly opposing the heliocentric system model is any different than the church adamantly opposing evolution now.

Can you not look at history and see that your book of perfection is always proven wrong in due time? The only thing between the worldly acceptance of evolution, including all mainstream religious people, is simply time. Nothing is going to change except time...

Just like when Galileo was SHOWING the church views of the solar system with his telescope way back when... and they stubbornly clung to the same book you're referencing now as the divine truth for so long, until society reached the point where to think the sun orbited the earth meant you were a social retard....

In time the same will be true of evolution vs the story of Adam and Eve. It's inevitable that truth will win out over fairy tale.

You act as if people like myself are "attacking" the bible. The truth is, the bible is simply in error and people like you refuse to accept the fact that a story book written by ignorant men (by present standards) is going to be WRONG in light of all the new evidence gained by man over the course of the thousands of years since....

Believing something without evidence, and with a mountain of evidence to the contrary, doesn't make you noble, loyal or just. It makes you a stubborn, arrogant asshole.
 
Serious question...

Do you believe in Santa? Why or why not?

I no longer believe in Santa Claus, at one time I believed wholeheartedly in him. I don't feel that I have suffered for my belief in him. Rather, I feel that some of the best "magic of childhood" is wrapped up in belief of fictional characters.

I'm a Christian. I believe in God, I believe that God's child, Jesus, was born and lived on Earth as an example to us all. I believe that Jesus died for our sins. I believe that there is a Heaven and a Hell. I believe that someone who strives to live a good life and when that person sins, is repentant of those sins, will go to Heaven.

I don't have irrefutable proof that there is a God. I believe because I can't LOGICALLY find reasons for people having a soul. If there is no God to animate us, we should be vegetables. That spark that makes us human isn't some chemical reaction that occurs in out brains, it has to come from something larger than us.

Faith is defined as "belief that is not based on proof". I don't need physical proof that there is a God. I don't have to be able to hold it or see it or read it to believe. I believe because something inside of me, something intrinsic to me tells me that there is a higher power at work in all out lives.

If I get to the end of my life and find that there is nothing for us but to be worm food, what has my faith cost me? I get warm fuzzies when I pray, I believe that striving to be a good person will allow me into Heaven, I have a friend in God, to talk to when I feel like I can't talk to any of my tangible friends. None of that is taking anything away from me, in fact, in my opinion, it improves the quality of my life.

On the other hand, if I refuse to believe because I can't hold some kind of definite proof in my hands, and we get to the end and discover "oh HOLY ****, there is a God, I denied him, and now I'm spending eternity in hell" that's gonna suck alot.
 
I no longer believe in Santa Claus, at one time I believed wholeheartedly in him. I don't feel that I have suffered for my belief in him. Rather, I feel that some of the best "magic of childhood" is wrapped up in belief of fictional characters.

I'm a Christian. I believe in God, I believe that God's child, Jesus, was born and lived on Earth as an example to us all. I believe that Jesus died for our sins. I believe that there is a Heaven and a Hell. I believe that someone who strives to live a good life and when that person sins, is repentant of those sins, will go to Heaven.

I don't have irrefutable proof that there is a God. I believe because I can't LOGICALLY find reasons for people having a soul. If there is no God to animate us, we should be vegetables. That spark that makes us human isn't some chemical reaction that occurs in out brains, it has to come from something larger than us.

You believe in God because you don't understand how muscle works? If it's God giving us the ability to move, then why can I take a dead pig, cut it's leg off, apply voltage to the muscle and it contracts and as I release the voltage it relaxes again, just like when the pig's brain sent the same signals to it when it was alive?

Why can I probe my own muscle and with an osscilloscope WATCH my own signal to fire any muscle on my body as I command that muscle to move with my brain? Why can I SEE that voltage signal go up perfectly proportionate to the voltage signal it's receiving, that I'm viewing on the scope??? Is it a miracle that the muscle burns glucose and oxygen to produce the voltages required to power itself? Is it a miracle that our digestive track produces that fuel by removing nutrients from the foods we eat?

For something so miraculous, it sure is easy to replicate.


Otherwise feel free to stop eating for a year and tell me how that whole "soul power" thing works out for you. Or, just severe the connections at the base of the brain and get back to me on how "animated" you are without any wiring to connect the signals produced in the brain to the muscle you think moves by the miracle of God...

The basis for finding wonderment in things you describe above lies in the requirement that you not UNDERSTAND how these things actually work. If you did, the miracle is gone, and you're right back to the nitty-gritty of the world as it actually is.


These are the specific reasons why you get to choose to "believe" in what you described above and I don't. Since I actually know how muscle tissue works I can't share your bliss... Neither can the OP, or anyone with a medical degree, or understanding of the human body.



Faith is defined as "belief that is not based on proof". I don't need physical proof that there is a God. I don't have to be able to hold it or see it or read it to believe. I believe because something inside of me, something intrinsic to me tells me that there is a higher power at work in all out lives.


Right now I can just as easily tell you that no matter what you say, and without ANY proof, that I honestly believe that 2 + 2 = 5. How can you argue with that? You can't. I can believe whatever I choose. Now does that have ANY effect on the actual sum of 2 and 2? Absolutely not. It was 4 before I believed it was 5 and it will continue to be 4 long after I'm dead.

Secondly, I'm not arguing for or against God. I'm arguing against falsehoods. Anything that is not true. The stories man has written about God are largely erroneous, and childish in nature. They mar the ability of people to truly understand their world, and in so doing also detract from people's abilities to raise their own standards of living based on ideas gained through a true understanding of their surroundings, and their inner-workings. Not on fairy tale stories about their surroundings.

Lastly,

"belief that is not based on proof"

That is literally insane. And even worse is the fact that you not only believe in something with no supporting evidence, but also in the face of contradictory evidence!

That is not rational. That is not logical.

Luckily for you, an irrational and illogical thought process is the main pre-req to being religious. So I guess you're all set. In ways that Ponder and myself are excluded from.



If I get to the end of my life and find that there is nothing for us but to be worm food, what has my faith cost me?

Potentially, quite a few things...

If you practice your faith in the wrong setting, prepare to be killed by others who also share your lack of rationality and logic and who might kill you for not believing in their faith of choice. Or are you oblivious to the fact that religion is the single greatest source of murder on the face of the planet, and it always has been? Missed that one? Or chose to ignore it, because it conflicted with the warm and fuzzies?

Secondly....

People working under false information will often times make poor decisions based on that bad intel.

Lets say for argument's sake that someone actually thought women had one less rib than men, because they read the story of Adam and Eve and took it to heart. Would we expect this of say, a surgeon? How would you feel if your doctor was feeling along your ribs and thought he had found the root of your stomach pains when he noticed you had an extra rib that only men should have, and that in your female body that extra rib was probably intruding on your internal organs and must be surgically removed???

I mean are you serious? Oh, oh, oh, or is this one of those times where the bible isn't to be taken literally???

:doh:



I get warm fuzzies when I pray, I believe that striving to be a good person will allow me into Heaven, I have a friend in God, to talk to when I feel like I can't talk to any of my tangible friends. None of that is taking anything away from me, in fact, in my opinion, it improves the quality of my life.

Well if the conversation involves dialogue from both parties I've got some bad news.... it's Schizophrenia, and it's not treatable. If however the conversation is one way, then why not just sort these things out on your own? After all, in reality every conversation you've ever had was manufactured in YOUR BRAIN.... You realize that everything you see, smell, touch, taste and do in your dreams is ALL produced from YOUR BRAIN right? So if you can have such detail and think you're actually doing those things when you're actually unconscious and dreaming, what on earth would make a conversation in your head even make your brain break a sweat? That's a small time task for the brain. Everyone reasons through things internally. Only some of us give a name to our conscience and pretend it's someone else though.



On the other hand, if I refuse to believe because I can't hold some kind of definite proof in my hands, and we get to the end and discover "oh HOLY ****, there is a God, I denied him, and now I'm spending eternity in hell" that's gonna suck alot.

I love the fact that your "better safe than sorry" philosophy doesn't apply to ANY of the zillion OTHER religions that ALSO say to not believe is to spend eternity in the worst imaginable place, yada, yada, yada....

I suppose the other lebbentybillion people believing full and well that because you don't pray to Mecca, and take Allah to be your one true God that you're burning in hell for all of eternity are all just full of sh*t???

You this much better than them???

They have a book too. Just as cool as yours. Maybe even thicker..... :eek:

Divine word of Allah no less.

All that just a bunch of bull? YOUR religion is the "right" one???


If you've got even a SHRED of intelligence you can PLAINLY see how PAINFULLY ARROGANT that is.......


:smirk:
 
Last edited:
I have been in sticky situations where I felt like there is something or someone with me or helping me get through. Can't explain just felt it.

I have felt this so I beleive.

Would be safe to say that you have never attempted to "find God"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top